|
iAdvertiser Disclosure
Advertiser Disclosure
Some institutions listed may have a business relationship with MonitorBankRates. Our proprietary systems independently track and verify all rates. Advertiser relationships do not influence our Safety Ratings, Star Ratings, Texas Ratio calculations, or the rates shown.
 Allegany First Federal Credit Union Rates & Review September 2026
Content reviewed by
Brian McKay
Brian McKayFounder & Data ArchitectExpertise
Brian is the Founder of MonitorBankRates.com. For over 18 years, he has utilized his background in enterprise infrastructure to engineer proprietary systems that track rates from over 8,000 financial institutions.
Read Full Bio →
Editorial Disclosure
The rates displayed are actual, verified rates sourced directly from the official websites of banks and credit unions. Our editorial content is independent of any advertiser relationships.
✓Fact Checked
Rates Last Updated and Verified: September 21, 2026
Allegany First Federal Credit Union's 24 Month CDs rates are at 0.60%, 18 Month CDs rates are at 0.50%, 12 Month CDs rates are at 0.40%, 6 Month CDs rates are at 0.30%. Allegany First Federal Credit Union's Personal Loan Rates are as low as 7.49%. MonitorBankRates evaluates the financial stability of Allegany First Federal Credit Union with a 5.0 Star Rating, an A+ Overall Health Grade, and a Texas Ratio of 2.10%. Rates last updated and verified on 09/21/2026. Allegany First Federal Credit Union money market rates, and other rates, are continually updated to reflect market conditions. We recommend checking back frequently to get the best money market rates and other rates available. Have you opened an account or have any experiences at Allegany First Federal Credit Union? Share your experience about Allegany First Federal Credit Union by leaving a review below, or read customer reviews before you decide to use Allegany First Federal Credit Union. Allegany First Federal Credit Union
Allegany First FCU 27 W Main St
https://www.alleganyfirstfcu.com Fillmore, NY 14735 
Allegany First Federal Credit Union CD Rates
Allegany First Federal Credit Union Savings Rates
Allegany First Federal Credit Union Auto Loan Rates
Allegany First Federal Credit Union RV, Boat and Powersport Loan Rates
Allegany First Federal Credit Union Personal Loan Rates
Allegany First Federal Credit Union Other Rates
Financial Health HistoryAllegany First Federal Credit Union’s Texas Ratio rose from 0.44% in Q2 2023 to 2.10% in Q1 2026, so its financial health has stayed very strong over the past 12 quarters. Over the same period its Star Rating moved from 5.0 to 5.0. Lower Texas Ratios are healthier — this credit union’s entire history sits far below the 15% threshold for the MBR Verified Healthy badge. Hover over or tap a point for that quarter’s figures. Swipe the chart sideways to see every quarter.
Texas Ratio, left axis (lower is healthier)MBR Star Rating, right axis (1 to 5)Health Grade
Powered by
MonitorBankRates
How to read this chart: the two lines move in opposite directions by design. The Texas Ratio (blue) measures trouble, so a rising blue line means more non-performing assets against capital. The Star Rating (green) and Health Grade chips measure strength, so they fall when the Texas Ratio climbs and recover when it drops. Show the quarterly figures
Source: NCUA 5300 call reports, MonitorBankRates analysis. Ratings shown are recomputed for each quarter with the current methodology and exclude member reviews.
Methodology & Data SourcesMonitorBankRates Star Rating
Our rating for Allegany First Federal Credit Union is derived from comprehensive financial data published quarterly by the NCUA. Our proprietary rating system evaluates financial stability (including the Texas Ratio and capitalization) and combines it with member feedback (user reviews) to help you make informed banking decisions.
Texas Ratio
We calculate the Texas Ratio using standard industry methodology. This ratio compares the credit union's non-performing assets to its tangible common equity and loan loss reserves to assess financial health.
Rate Data Aggregation
We gather Allegany First Federal Credit Union rates using proprietary online rate aggregation technology. Our systems scan constantly to provide the most recent rates available to our visitors.
Disclaimer: Interest rates are variable and subject to change without notice. While we strive for accuracy, rates can change rapidly based on market conditions.
It is always advisable to check with Allegany First Federal Credit Union's official website for the most current offers and terms.
Credit Union Profile & Overview
Credit Union Name
Allegany First Federal Credit Union
Website
https://www.alleganyfirstfcu.com
Address
27 W Main St,
Fillmore, NY 14735
Phone
585-567-4103
Fax
585-567-8993
President
Randa Harrington
CEO
Michaela Tucker
Full-Time Employees
4
Part-Time Employees
0
Branch Locations
1
ATM Locations
0
NCUA Insured
✓ Yes — Up to $250,000 per depositor
FinancialsMonitorBankRates Star Rating
5.0 / 5.0 ★
Overall Health & Safety Grade
A+ (99/100)
Texas Ratio
2.10%
Return on Assets (ROA)
0.3868%
Return on Equity (ROE)
2.7183%
Non-Performing Loans Ratio (NPL)
1.08%
Total Assets
25,571,739
Total Amount of Shares and Deposits
21,884,992
Total Shares and Deposits < 1 Year
21,744,819
Total Shares and Deposits 1 3 Years
140,172
Total Uninsured Member Shares and Deposits > $250K (A+A1+B+C+D+E)
1,809,640
Total Uninsured Shares and Deposits > $250K (F+J)
1,809,640
Total Insured Shares and Deposits > $250K (item 17 less item K)
20,075,352
Total Interest Expense (Sum of items 6 8)
19,480
Share Certificates
11
Number of Accounts for Share Drafts
1,482
Number of Accounts for Regular Shares
2,471
Net Income (unless the amount is already included in Undivided Earnings)
118,030
Net Worth Classification if credit union is not new (Based upon Call Report data only See instructions)
Well Capitalized
Net Worth Classification if credit union is a new credit union
Well Capitalized
Total Cash on Deposit (Amounts Deposited in Financial Institutions)
11,600,007
Total Liabilities
21,933,235
Source: NCUA — Last Updated 03/31/2026
Customer Reviews
There are no reviews for Allegany First Federal Credit Union yet. Feel free to create one below.
Looking for more bank and credit union reviews?
Visit our Community Reviews hub to read what other members are saying, ask questions, and join the conversation.
Add Your Rating and Review for Allegany First Federal Credit Union
Frequently Asked Questions About Allegany First Federal Credit UnionHow many branches does Allegany First Federal Credit Union operate?Allegany First Federal Credit Union currently maintains approximately multiple branch location(s). Physical branches allow members to access in-person services such as notary consultations and safe deposit boxes. Is a member application needed to join Allegany First Federal Credit Union?Yes, to access services at Allegany First Federal Credit Union, a member application is required. As a credit union, membership is based on specific eligibility criteria such as where you live, work, or your organizational affiliations. Is there a first-time homebuyer program?Currently, Allegany First Federal Credit Union does not list a specific first-time homebuyer program, but they provide a range of mortgage and home equity products to assist members with property financing. Are credit management and repair services offered?While formal credit repair services are not currently listed, Allegany First Federal Credit Union provides members with tools to manage their accounts and build a solid financial history. Does Allegany First Federal Credit Union offer online and mobile banking?Most modern institutions like Allegany First Federal Credit Union provide digital access. This includes the ability to check balances, transfer funds, deposit checks via mobile app, and view statements online. You can usually find these services at their official website: https://www.alleganyfirstfcu.com. Current Allegany First Federal Credit Union Rates
Retrieved from our database of financial products. Rates subject to change.
Compare to Other Credit Unions
New Brunswick Postal Federal Credit Union
Generations United Federal Credit Union
UPSTATE TELCO Federal Credit Union
M-O Federal Credit Union
First Choice Financial Federal Credit Union
Sherwin Williams Employee Credit Union
Grand Junction Federal Credit Union
Cambridge Firefighters Federal Credit Union
Premier One Credit Union
Teamsters Local #238 Credit Union
Elizabeth NJ Firemens Federal Credit Union
Twin Rivers Federal Credit Union
Gary Police Department Employees Federal Credit Union
Olivet Baptist Credit Union
MC Federal Credit Union
Flint Federal Credit Union
UFirst Federal Credit Union
Delta Federal Credit Union
LEVO
Mountain Star Federal Credit Union
Linkage Credit Union
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
