☰

Quick Poll The Fed raised rates 0.25% on Sept. 16. Will you move money into a higher-yield account?

Home›
Banks›
First Federal Savings of Middletown

iAdvertiser Disclosure

First Federal Savings of Middletown Rates & Review September 2026

Q: Are credit management and repair services offered?

While formal credit repair services are not currently listed, First Federal Savings of Middletown provides members with tools to manage their accounts and build a solid financial history.

Content reviewed by

Brian McKay

| Editorial Disclosure | ✓Fact Checked | Rates Last Updated and Verified: September 23, 2026

First Federal Savings of Middletown rates are not currently in our database, but you can compare rates from other banks and credit unions we track: 12-month CD rates are currently at 2.85%, 6-month CD rates at 2.75% and 3-month CD rates at 2.56%. Savings rates are at 0.89% and money market rates are at 1.22%. Mortgage rates on 30-year fixed loans are around 7.01%. These rates come from our rate database, not First Federal Savings of Middletown, and you can see how they compare in the First Federal Savings of Middletown rate tables below. MonitorBankRates evaluates the financial stability of First Federal Savings of Middletown with a 5.0 Star Rating, an A+ Overall Health Grade, and a Texas Ratio of 0.00%. Database rates last updated and verified on 09/23/2026.

First Federal Savings of Middletown money market rates, and other rates, are continually updated to reflect market conditions. We recommend checking back frequently to get the best money market rates and other rates available. Have you opened an account or have any experiences at First Federal Savings of Middletown? Share your experience about First Federal Savings of Middletown by leaving a review below, or read customer reviews before you decide to use First Federal Savings of Middletown.

Verified Healthy 2026 Use This Badge on Your Bank Website

Overall Health & Safety Grade

A+

Exceptional Health Score: 100/100

MonitorBankRates Rating

5.0

Exceptional Out of 5.0 Stars

Texas Ratio

0.00%

Perfect Lower than avg

Health Trend

Very strong 12 quarters

Full history ›

First Federal Savings of Middletown

22 James St
Middletown, NY 10940

https://www.firstfederalmiddletown.com

Current Rate Availability

We're not currently displaying rates for First Federal Savings of Middletown, but our database is updated constantly, so check back soon for the latest offers.

Are you with First Federal Savings of Middletown? We'd love to add your institution's rates. Contact us to get your institution's rates listed on MonitorBankRates.

Financial Health History

First Federal Savings of Middletown’s Texas Ratio stayed near 0.00% in Q3 2023 to 0.00% in Q2 2026, so its financial health has stayed very strong over the past 12 quarters. Over the same period its Star Rating moved from 5.0 to 5.0. Lower Texas Ratios are healthier — this bank’s entire history sits far below the 15% threshold for the MBR Verified Healthy badge. Hover over or tap a point for that quarter’s figures.

Swipe the chart sideways to see every quarter.

Texas Ratio, left axis (lower is healthier)MBR Star Rating, right axis (1 to 5)Health Grade

How to read this chart: the two lines move in opposite directions by design. The Texas Ratio (blue) measures trouble, so a rising blue line means more non-performing assets against capital. The Star Rating (green) and Health Grade chips measure strength, so they fall when the Texas Ratio climbs and recover when it drops.

Show the quarterly figures

Quarter	Total assets	Texas Ratio	Star Rating	Health Grade
June 30, 2026	$188M	0.00%	5.0	A+
March 31, 2026	$186M	0.52%	5.0	A+
December 31, 2025	$182M	0.53%	5.0	A+
September 30, 2025	$181M	0.53%	5.0	A+
June 30, 2025	$181M	0.54%	5.0	A+
March 31, 2025	$183M	0.55%	5.0	A+
December 31, 2024	$180M	1.17%	5.0	A+
September 30, 2024	$177M	0.00%	5.0	A+
June 30, 2024	$173M	0.00%	5.0	A+
March 31, 2024	$173M	0.00%	5.0	A+
December 31, 2023	$169M	0.00%	5.0	A+
September 30, 2023	$167M	0.00%	5.0	A+

Source: FDIC call reports, MonitorBankRates analysis. Ratings shown are recomputed for each quarter with the current methodology and exclude member reviews.

Methodology & Data Sources

MonitorBankRates Star Rating: Our rating for First Federal Savings of Middletown is derived from comprehensive financial data published quarterly by the FDIC. Our proprietary rating system evaluates financial stability (including the Texas Ratio and capitalization) and combines it with customer feedback (user reviews) to help you make informed banking decisions.

Texas Ratio: We calculate the Texas Ratio using standard industry methodology. This ratio compares the bank's non-performing assets to its tangible common equity and loan loss reserves to assess financial health.

Rate Data Aggregation: We gather First Federal Savings of Middletown rates using proprietary online rate aggregation technology. Our systems scan constantly to provide the most recent rates available to our visitors.

Disclaimer: Interest rates are variable and subject to change without notice. While we strive for accuracy, rates can change rapidly based on market conditions. It is always advisable to check with First Federal Savings of Middletown's official website for the most current offers and terms.

Bank Profile & Overview

Institution Name First Federal Savings of Middletown

FDIC Certificate # 28712

Address 22 James St, Middletown, NY 10940 · Orange

Website https://www.firstfederalmiddletown.com

Established 18880101

FDIC Insurance Date 19890809

Domestic Offices 1

Total Branches 1

Regulator OCC

FDIC Insured ✓ Yes — Up to $250,000

Financial Health & Assets

A+

Overall Health Grade Score: 100/100

5.0

Exceptional Out of 5.0 Stars

0.00%

Texas Ratio Nat'l avg: 5.85%

Return on Assets (ROA) 1.8594%

Return on Equity (ROE) 5.0800%

Non-Performing Loans (NPL) 0.00%

Total Assets $187,963,000

Total Deposits $112,251,000

Equity Capital $68,592,000

Net Income $1,722,000

Headquarters Middletown

Total Branches and Offices 1

Source: FDIC | Last Updated 06/30/2026

2026 MBR Health & Safety Badge

First Federal Savings of Middletown earned the Verified Healthy badge

Display this badge on your website to show visitors your 2026 MonitorBankRates recognition. The badge links back to this profile page for independent verification.

Copy the HTML below and paste it into your website where you’d like the badge to appear. The badge image is hosted on MonitorBankRates — no need to download or upload anything.

<a href="https://monitorbankrates.com/banks/first-federal-savings-of-middletown-rates-review-28712">
  <img src="https://www.monitorbankrates.com/wp-content/uploads/badges/mbr-badge-tier-c-2026.svg"
       alt="MonitorBankRates Verified Healthy Badge 2026"
       width="160" height="160">
</a>

Learn more about the MBR Health & Safety Badge program on our methodology page.

Customer Reviews

There are no reviews for First Federal Savings of Middletown yet. Feel free to create one below.

Looking for more bank and credit union reviews? Visit our Community Reviews hub to read what other members are saying, ask questions, and join the conversation.

Average Rating

☆☆☆☆☆

Total Reviews

Add Your Rating and Review for First Federal Savings of Middletown

Frequently Asked Questions About First Federal Savings of Middletown

How many branches does First Federal Savings of Middletown operate?

First Federal Savings of Middletown currently maintains approximately 1 branch location(s). Physical branches allow members to access in-person services such as notary consultations and safe deposit boxes.

Is there a first-time homebuyer program?

Currently, First Federal Savings of Middletown does not list a specific first-time homebuyer program, but they provide a range of mortgage and home equity products to assist members with property financing.

Are credit management and repair services offered?

While formal credit repair services are not currently listed, First Federal Savings of Middletown provides members with tools to manage their accounts and build a solid financial history.

Does First Federal Savings of Middletown offer online and mobile banking?

Most modern institutions like First Federal Savings of Middletown provide digital access. This includes the ability to check balances, transfer funds, deposit checks via mobile app, and view statements online. You can usually find these services at their official website: https://www.firstfederalmiddletown.com.