|
iAdvertiser Disclosure
Advertiser Disclosure
Some institutions listed may have a business relationship with MonitorBankRates. Our proprietary systems independently track and verify all rates. Advertiser relationships do not influence our Safety Ratings, Star Ratings, Texas Ratio calculations, or the rates shown.
 First Federal Savings of Middletown Rates & Review April 2026
Content reviewed by
Brian McKay
Brian McKayFounder & Data ArchitectExpertise
Brian is the Founder of MonitorBankRates.com. For over 18 years, he has utilized his background in enterprise infrastructure to engineer proprietary systems that track rates from over 8,000 financial institutions.
Read Full Bio →
Editorial Disclosure
The rates displayed are actual, verified rates sourced directly from the official websites of banks and credit unions. Our editorial content is independent of any advertiser relationships.
✓Fact Checked
Rates Last Updated: April 23, 2026
You can compare First Federal Savings of Middletown rates to other rates in our database, including 12-month CD rates currently at 2.78%, 6-month CD rates at 3.50% and 3-month CD rates at 0.90%. Savings rates are at 0.75% and money market rates are at 0.10%. Mortgage rates on 30-year fixed loans are around 6.12%. All these rates can be compared to First Federal Savings of Middletown rates. MonitorBankRates evaluates the financial stability of First Federal Savings of Middletown with a 5.0 Star Rating and an A+ Overall Health Grade. Rates were last updated on 04/23/2026. First Federal Savings of Middletown money market rates, and other rates, are continually updated to reflect market conditions. We recommend checking back frequently to get the best money market rates and other rates available. Have you opened an account or have any experiences at First Federal Savings of Middletown? Share your experience about First Federal Savings of Middletown by leaving a review below, or read customer reviews before you decide to use First Federal Savings of Middletown. First Federal Savings of Middletown
22 James St
Middletown, NY 10940 
Current Rate AvailabilityWe do not have First Federal Savings of Middletown rates right now, but we are constantly updating our database so check back often for updated rates. Methodology & Data SourcesMonitorBankRates Star Rating: Our rating for First Federal Savings of Middletown is derived from comprehensive financial data published quarterly by the FDIC. Our proprietary rating system evaluates financial stability (including the Texas Ratio and capitalization) and combines it with customer feedback (user reviews) to help you make informed banking decisions. Texas Ratio: We calculate the Texas Ratio using standard industry methodology. This ratio compares the bank's non-performing assets to its tangible common equity and loan loss reserves to assess financial health. Rate Data Aggregation: We gather First Federal Savings of Middletown rates using proprietary online rate aggregation technology. Our systems scan constantly to provide the most recent rates available to our visitors.
Disclaimer: Interest rates are variable and subject to change without notice. While we strive for accuracy, rates can change rapidly based on market conditions.
It is always advisable to check with First Federal Savings of Middletown's official website for the most current offers and terms.
Bank Profile & Overview
Institution Name
First Federal Savings of Middletown
FDIC Certificate #
28712
Address
22 James St,
Middletown, NY 10940 · Orange
Established
01/01/1888
FDIC Insurance Date
08/09/1989
Domestic Offices
1
Total Branches
1
Regulator
OCC
FDIC Insured
✓ Yes — Up to $250,000
Financial Health & AssetsA+
Overall Health Grade
Score: 100/100
5.0
Exceptional
Out of 5.0 Stars
0.00%
Texas Ratio
Nat'l avg: 5.85%
Return on Assets (ROA)
2.0586%
Return on Equity (ROE)
5.8500%
Non-Performing Loans (NPL)
0.00%
Total Assets
$181,779,000
Total Deposits
$107,979,000
Equity Capital
$66,870,000
Net Income
$3,362,000
Headquarters
Middletown
Total Offices
1
Source: FDIC | Last Updated 12/31/2025
Frequently Asked Questions About First Federal Savings of MiddletownIs First Federal Savings of Middletown a safe place to deposit money?Yes, First Federal Savings of Middletown is considered a safe financial institution. Your accounts are federally insured by the FDIC (Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation) up to $250,000 per depositor, for each account ownership category. How many branches does First Federal Savings of Middletown operate?First Federal Savings of Middletown currently maintains approximately 1 branch location(s). Physical branches allow members to access in-person services such as notary consultations and safe deposit boxes. Is there a first-time homebuyer program?Currently, First Federal Savings of Middletown does not list a specific first-time homebuyer program, but they provide a range of mortgage and home equity products to assist members with property financing. Are credit management and repair services offered?While formal credit repair services are not currently listed, First Federal Savings of Middletown provides members with tools to manage their accounts and build a solid financial history. Does First Federal Savings of Middletown offer online and mobile banking?Most modern institutions like First Federal Savings of Middletown provide digital access. This includes the ability to check balances, transfer funds, deposit checks via mobile app, and view statements online. You can usually find these services at their official website: https://www.firstfederalmiddletown.com. Compare to Other Banks
Citizens Bank Minnesota
Lyons Federal Bank
Morton Community Bank
Atkins Savings B&T
Cornerstone Bank Fargo, ND
Woodsboro Bank
The Citizens Bank (AR)
The Clay City Banking Co.
Longview Bank
Scale Bank
F&M Bank Caldwell, OH
Bank Five Nine
Grand Ridge National Bank
FirstOak Bank
Home SB of Wapakoneta
Magnolia Bank
Bank of Grain Valley
First Westroads Bank
Lakeside Bank IL
First Federal Bank of Wisconsin
Rocky Mountain Bank
|
